EDB — 27H

view in whole PDF view in whole HTML

View

English

Remark 44

[27H]Historical notes.

  • The proposition ”\(|A^ 2|=|A|\) holds for every infinite set” is equivalent to the axiom of choice. This was demonstrated by Tarski [ 26 ] in 1928 ; the article is online and downloadable and contains other surprising equivalences. See also [ 24 ] Part 1 Section 7 page 140 assertion CN6.

  • Jan Mycielski [ 21 ] reports: «Tarski told me the following story. He tried to publish his theorem (stated above) in the Comptes Rendus Acad. Sci. Paris but Fréchet and Lebesgue refused to present it. Fréchet wrote that an implication between two well known propositions is not a new result. Lebesgue wrote that an implication between two false propositions is of no interest. And Tarski said that after this misadventure he never tried to publish in the Comptes Rendus».

    This anecdote shows how in the past (before the works of Godel and Cohen  [ , even the most respected mathematician had a feeble grasp of the importance of the Axiom of Choice.

Download PDF
Bibliography
  • [27] Alfred Tajtelbaum-Tarski. Sur quelques théorèmes qui équivalent à l’axiome du choix. Fundamenta Mathematicae, 5(1):147–154, 1924.
  • [25] H. Rubin and J.E. Rubin. Equivalents of the Axiom of Choice, II. ISSN. Elsevier Science, 1985. ISBN 9780080887654. URL https://books.google.it/books?id=LSsbBU9FesQC.
  • [22] Jan Mycielski. A system of axioms of set theory for the rationalists. volume 53, pages 206–213, 2006. URL https://www.ams.org/journals/notices/200602/200602FullIssue.pdf.
  • [7] John L. Bell. The Axiom of Choice. In Edward N. Zalta, editor, The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University, Winter 2021 edition, 2021.

Book index
  • cardinality
Managing blob in: Multiple languages
This content is available in: Italian English